Real Estate News

Some Dangerous Conditions Are Just Plain Obvious


Written By: Bob Hunt
Monday, August 14, 2017

The good news is that a California Appellate Court has upheld a grant of summary judgment essentially, a dismissal in favor of a real estate company that was being sued for negligence. Jacques Jacobs et al. v. Coldwell Banker, Second Appellate District Court of Appeal, July 25, 2017.

The not-so-good news is that the opinion has not been certified for publication.

Well discuss both.

Coldwell Banker had listed a vacant, bank-owned property. The backyard had an empty swimming pool with a diving board. According to the court record, Dianne Garnett, the agent, conducted a visual inspection of the property.

"After examining each room in the house, Garnett spent 20 to 30 minutes inspecting the backyard, including the diving board. She did not observe any breaks, cracks or other visible damage in the diving board. The only dangerous condition she observed was the empty swimming pool.

"Garnett retained Clearflo Pools Clearflo to inspect the swimming pool and >"Before the property was viewed by any potential buyers, Garnett prepared an MLS listing for the property. The listing stated: Please use CAUTION around the empty pool."

The record goes on to say that Mr. and Mrs. Jacobs were interested in purchasing the property. On August 30, 2014, they met with their agent to view the property. "Jacques [Mr. Jacobs], a licensed contractor who regularly performs tile work in and around swimming pools, noticed that the backyard swimming pool was empty. Jacques knew he should stay away from the edge of the empty pool because it would hurt if [he] fell in.

"Jacques wanted to see over the fence to assess whether someone from the adjacent road could jump over the fence into the backyard. To get a better view, he stood on the base of the diving board. After standing on the diving board for 10 to 30 seconds, Jacques felt the board break loose from its base. The board slid forward and Jacques fell into the empty swimming pool, sustaining serious injuries."

Naturally, the Jacobs sued Coldwell Banker. They alleged negligence and argued, among other things, that Coldwell Banker had failed in its duty to warn Mr. Jacobs that the empty pool was a dangerous condition.

The trial court granted Coldwell Banker its motion for summary judgment, and the case was appealed. The Appellate Court spent some time discussing the issue of Coldwell Bankers duty, or the lack thereof, to protect Mr. Jacobs from "the open and obvious danger of the empty pool"

The court noted that whether or not a duty exists is determined by a variety of factors, among them "... the foreseeability of harm to the plaintiff, the burden to the defendant and the consequences to the community of imposing the duty."

The court then turned to a variety of earlier cases. It noted this: "Foreseeability of harm is typically absent when a dangerous condition is open and obvious... Generally, if a danger is so obvious that a person could reasonably be expected to see it, the condition itself serves as a warning, and the landowner is under no further duty to remedy or warn of the condition In that situation, owners and possessors of land are entitled to assume others will perceive the obvious and take action to avoid the dangerous condition." [my emphasis]

Next, it pointed out an exception to that rule: "... obviousness will not negate a duty of care when it is foreseeable that because of necessity or other circumstances, a person may choose to encounter the condition." Examples were given, such as a case where walking across a narrow plank was necessitated by a job requirement that a person had to access a faucet on the other side.

In this case, though, there was no such necessity. "Although [Mr. Jacobs] wished to look over the fence, he was not compelled to do so It was not reasonably foreseeable that he or anyone else would use the diving board for that purpose." "Accordingly," the Appellate Court said, "we agree with the trial courts conclusion that the undisputed facts indicate that it was not reasonably foreseeable that [Mr. Jacobs] would expose himself to the risks associated with the empty pool, as he was neither required nor invited to do so."

That this opinion was not certified for publication means that it cannot be cited or >Bob Hunt is a director of the California Association of Realtorsreg;. He is the author of Real Estate the Ethical Way. His email address is .

Copyright© 2017 Realty Times®. All Rights Reserved

 

Map SearchClick here for a free Market AnalysisBuyers: Search here for your Dream HomeSubscribe! Sign up to recieve our Newsletter!Real Estate Outlook
Facebook linkedin twitter youtube googleplus
Updated: Thursday, December 14, 2017


Why The Next Two Weeks May Be The Best Time To Buy New Construction All Year

If youre looking to buy a home and you would really like to get something in escrow before the end of the year, you might be facing a "slim pickens" situation. Inventory issues have ...
> Full Story

How To Create Year-Round Home Curb Appeal

Exceptional curb appeal will add to the enjoyment and value of your property and home. Maintaining your curb appeal throughout each season may pose its challenges, but with these tip...
> Full Story

Using Your Homes quot;Deadquot; Equity

Question. Our house is free and clear. We have a 100,000 home equity line of credit, and the interest rate is somewhere in the neighborhood of 7 percent. We itemize tax deduct...
> Full Story

Ask the HOA Expert: Repercussions When A Board Throws Out A Member Decision

Question: What are the possible repercussions when a board throws out a member decision voted on at the Annual Meeting?

Answer: If member approval is required to do w...
> Full Story

REALTOR Analysis Of Tax Bill Is Worth Examining

It is no secret that the National, State, and Local Realtorreg; associations are strongly opposed to certain provisions in both the House and Senate versions of the current tax refor...
> Full Story

Why Chinese Real Estate Investors Are Still Flocking To Canada

Despite taxes on foreign real estate buyers in the Vancouver and Toronto areas, Chinese interest in Canadian real estate continues to have an impact in both regions. In B.C., where t...
> Full Story

Purple Power: How To Use Pantones 2018 Color Of The Year

Seeing a whole lot of purple recently? Its not an homage to Prince. Its Pantones Color of the Year for 2018, and its about to be everywhere.

Pantone, the worlds leading color a...
> Full Story

The Introverts Guide to Hosting Holiday Get-Togethers

So you somehow got roped into hosting a holiday get-together this year, which means dozens of family members will be descending upon your house, and... this is your basic nightmare. ...
> Full Story

Get The Look: Transitional-Style Kitchen

Transitional >The Basics: Mixing Old and New

Fundamentally, transitional >

Often this means taking evocative traditional shapes and applying a contemporary finish to them....
> Full Story

What To Expect from Your Solar Energy This Winter

What happens when you >

Preparing for Winter

Winter is known for drastic changes in temperatures above and below freezing. It is important to inspect your panels and r...
> Full Story



Copyright ©2017 - Realty Times®
All Rights Reserved.