Real Estate News

NAR, the DOJ and Procompetition


Written By: Blanche Evans
Thursday, April 19, 2018

On June 5, 2018, NAR can make its case that ldquo;the breadth and depth of competition in the real estate and brokerage industryrdquo; at a public workshop held by the DOJ and Federal Trade Commission. Part of the strategy is to share a report by independent economist Frederk Flyer, PhD, titled Procompetitive Benefits of Policies Limiting Access to Multiple Listing Service Data.

Flyer asserts that much of the criticism of limiting information access is concern that consumers of third-party data aggregators of real estate listings, such as Zillow and Trulia, will not have access to full MLS information.

However, what the DOJ and FTC fail to recognize, is that these websites compete in a different antitrust market, argues Flyer, as neither Zillow nor Trulia broker real estate transactions as licensed real estate practitioners do. In fact, part of their business models is to provide lead generation services to the brokers using the brokersrsquo; and their competitorsrsquo; data.

ldquo;Real estate websites such as Zillow and Trulia are in the business of vying for Internet ldquo;eyeballsrdquo; and are not in the business of providing brokerage services; hence limiting these sitesrsquo; access to proprietary MLS data does not harm consumers of brokerage services nor does it limit their access to information,rdquo; writes Flyer.

ldquo;These sites are not even essential to consumers who use actual brokerage services, since these data aggregation sites do not provide consumers of brokerage services with any greater access to information.

And that could be the key sticking point ndash; greater access to information. Is a Zestimate greater information? Is access to advertisers greater information? Is allowing brokers to advertise their services on top of their competitorsrsquo; listings greater information?

As we discussed ad nauseum in the 2000s, the DOJ and Federal Trade Commission believe that associations restricting MLS data to third-parties limits competition, giving NAR and its subsidiaries a monopoly that harms consumers. NARrsquo;s opposing view is that the forced sharing of MLS listing data with third-party websites benefits the websites, not consumers.

The establishment of the MLS, in which brokers share their listings with other brokers, in itself fosters competition among those members who pay for the service, requiring no obligation to allow third-parties to benefit financially from the collective listing data. It also keeps brokers from showing only their own listings as consumers can see that there are other homes available for sale or rent on association websites and consumer-facing access to the local MLS.

Nar General Counsel Katie Johnson explains that innovation isnrsquo;t spurred by providing unrestricted real estate data to technology companies.

States Johnson, ldquo;I can confirm that NAR has no plans to alter MLS policies mandating how property listings are displayed by online brokerages when the 2008 settlement agreement expires November 18, 2018.rdquo;

This should be interesting. Realty Times is open to new arguments from either side. So letrsquo;s throw it out there ndash; brokers, has sharing your listings via your MLS with third-party sites helped or hurt your business?



Copyright© 2018 Realty Times®. All Rights Reserved

 

Map SearchClick here for a free Market AnalysisBuyers: Search here for your Dream HomeSubscribe! Sign up to recieve our Newsletter!Real Estate Outlook
Facebook linkedin twitter youtube googleplus
Updated: Sunday, April 22, 2018


Freshen Up Your Home With Spring And Summer Updates

Updating your home can seem like a huge blank, especially if its been a while. But there are easier ways to freshen it up and make it look spring and summer ready that wont break the...
> Full Story

Dont Recarpet Your Home Before Reading This

Getting new carpet can be pricey, but it sure does look great when its done If youre getting ready to lay down some new stuff, or at least researching your options, you may have a bi...
> Full Story

9 Home Improvements That Can Help and Hurt Value

Home improvement can be taken as very demanding action, but there are also some ways of home improvement you can do yourself. Therefore, before you start with any, see what improveme...
> Full Story

Inside Tips On Outdoor Kitchens

Outdoor kitchens make dining al fresco at home more appealing than ever. A rebounding trend in outdoor living reveals more and more properties feature outdoor kitchens that once were...
> Full Story

Whats Wrong With Oklahoma?

As the two-week Oklahoma teachers strike ended last week, its clear that the rabidly red state has some serious problems, namely that oil money doesnt trickle down like economics are...
> Full Story

Get The Home You Want, Millennials: Smart Strategies For First-Time Homebuyers

Hey, Millennials. Come on into the real estate market We really need you to buy some homes so we can keep chugging along. Oh, wait. Prices are rising and so are interest rates, plus ...
> Full Story

Property Survey Always Wise, Often Required

Question: At our settlement recently, a lawyer charged us 150 for a survey. When we questioned this charge, we were told it was a lenders requirement and we could do nothing a...
> Full Story

Ask the HOA Expert: Admendments To Governing Documents

Question: Recently, our HOA members approved substantial amendments to the governing documents which include:

1. Sidewalks are now deemed common area even though the ...
> Full Story

Buyer Love Letters Often Work; But They Can Backfire Too

In many areas of the country, housing inventory is low and competition among buyers is intense. When that happens, many buyers agents will encourage their clients to submit a cover l...
> Full Story

Rising Land Values Threaten Viability Of Canadian Farms, Says Senate Report

Rising farmland prices are putting the family farm in Canada at risk, as good farmland is being converted for residential and commercial development. A report by the Senate Committee...
> Full Story



Copyright ©2018 - Realty Times®
All Rights Reserved.